PDA

View Full Version : OFW versus E2 for AZbox HD: a comparison...



Blagi
28-07-2011, 09:42 AM
Taken from AZboxHD.es forum...

Speaking for myself, I also use dual boot, as there are stronger points on both sides...

How about you? What would you suggest needs improving in E2 (I gave up on OFW, really...)?

I would add subtitles issue in E2!

What goes well and can be easily adjusted in OFW (say, playing a movie from NAS or USB stick, with a sub/srt file in the same or different folder), doesn't give me the same results with DDamir's plugin in E2.

DDamir's plugin has greater capability, with searching online for many subs - but it lacks easy, automatic syncing and/or adjusting, like in OFW, of Audio and Visual parts. It can be quite tricky and sometimes close to impossible, if you are not ready with the sub file beforehand, prior to a film commencing...

At least I haven't managed it properly yet...

So, how about you?

This is the original text:

OFW 5306 v. E2

OFW:

Multimedia = OK for most file types but not OK with high bitrate, demanding files, with high data throughput, because of the OFW LAN capacity ceiling (because OFW is full of bugs and loaded, hence we call it Bloatware)

Zaping = KO (slow)

Recordings = KO (I tried to NAS via LAN and new, fast and large USB memory stick, with poor results)

Picons = wouldn't know it's possible in OFW

EPG = work, thanx to Morser's GetEPG 2.5 but that is a bit slow and tasking and slows down the machine (nothing to do with Morser but OFW's bugs and overloaded nature - hence Bloatware!)

Emu = OK but not great, because of "extra layers" or "mediators" (tried them all, all are slower and less stable than in E2)

Browser = KO (unusable, unlike some other receivers, like Amico Alien)

Wifi = ??? (I don't have it)

Mounting - OK (NFS works fine but only using Priority Manager 1.8, mounting all the shared folders; CIFS is just working with OFW built-in tools/scripts!)

HW recognition via USB ports - OK

Teletext - OK!

Remote Control Unit - OK (better than E2, with a proper functionality of all the keys!)

E2 for AZbox HD

Multimedia = KO for most file types (video quickly not in sync with sound, most of the time, some formats not playable, even though they are playable in OFW)

Zaping = OK (fast)

Recordings = ??? (not tried it yet, sorry, due to USB mounting stability problem)

Picons = work

EPG = works

Emu = OK (tried OSCam and CCcam)

Browser = ???

Wifi = ??? (don't have it)

Mounting - KO (just 1 folder at a time, in NFS; CIFS not working!)

HW recognition via USB ports - KO (needs better capacity/capability and it must become more stable!)

Teletext - KO (NOT THERE AT ALL!)

Remote Control Unit - KO (needs better mapping and functionality of all the keys!)



Conclusion:

There are some things to be learnt from OFW, when we are talking about an overall superiority of E2 as an Operating System!

OFW is called BloatWare for a reason! E2, however, isn't perfect either...

Sat TV part of E2 is far superior (more capable, versatile, faster and more stable) to that of OFW, even if some parts are missing (Teletext, for instance) or not as good as OFW (channel list and editing it)!

Multimedia part in E2 is not there yet (all must be improved significantly) and E2 could learn a thing or three from OFW (like mounting capabilities)!

Additionally, in OFW internet browser and similar stuff is pretty naff/OFF/**** poor - but it isn't there at all in E2 and some stuff that is there (YouTube) isn't properly sorted yet!

ONWARD AND UPWARD!!!!!

Carp95
12-08-2011, 11:17 PM
Maybe you have to rewrite the above Blagi after 1.2 ;)

Blagi
13-08-2011, 01:56 AM
I hope so but I haven't had the chance to test yet...

Any hints, as to what you have in mind?

Blagi
15-08-2011, 09:48 AM
Anyone tried the Multimedia, guys?

Is it really OK - but after a long test, whole movie, a few of them, various formats etc.?

Briefly testing something sometimes is like no testing at all, as I figured out with previous versions. It turned out there were many problems, with sync, DVD, some formats etc.

So, anyone did the hard testing, please?